To Begin Again: Renewing Public Health’s Mental Model

Topics:
Public Health
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

In a Milbank Quarterly article published earlier this year, we described how health departments need to partner with community power-building organizations (CPBOs) to advance health equity. Called inside-outside strategies, one of the examples we shared was from Cook County, Illinois, where the health department began by building trust with two CPBOs. Trust presently is a much-discussed idea in public health, specifically how it has declined since the COVID-19 pandemic. The nature of this decline is complex and differs by income, race, ethnicity, rurality, history, and political persuasion, but the overall picture is stark — trust in the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), for instance, fell from 63% in September 2023 to 50% by September 2025.

Although there are numerous ideas for how to rebuild trust, we feel one undervalued point is that the public wants more respect from the institutions that purport to serve them. Inherent to that respect is a deeper understanding of the social conditions that people experience. Public health is adept at using epidemiological data to see population-level patterns of risk and disease and, at times, can point to the conditions that “determine” them, but that’s not the same as truly understanding people’s lives. As a consequence, many public health interventions fail to have a material and sustained impact among communities enduring the most challenging of conditions. And, while there are growing calls for this “lived experience” to influence how institutions operate, this is yet to happen at scale.

Engagement, Power, and the Collective

Community engagement is often suggested as a solution to understanding “lived experience.” Broadly speaking, we agree but community engagement is not one thing, it’s a spectrum with five levels of activity — informing, consulting with, involving, collaborating with, and deferring to communities. Evidence has shown that the deeper forms of engagement lead to better health and service outcomes, increased skills and confidence of those engaged, and trust and social cohesion in the community. Despite knowing these connections, public health has faced challenges in embracing these deeper forms.

Inherent in the deepest forms of engagement – collaborating with and deferring to communities — is the idea that institutions “share power” with communities. Power is a term that is used more rhetorically than scientifically in public health, and yet high-quality scholarship and practice has defined what it is, its many forms, and how it can be used to pursue social, environmental, and health equity. Indeed, a thorough understanding of power illustrates that, while it may be useful for public health to share its power, the profession needs to accept that it only has some forms of power, namely knowledge and moral authority, and that these forms are no longer enough to bring about health equity. Communities have other forms of power, such as collective action. Sharing power, then, is not a unidirectional activity but a bi-directional one that develops the collective power of both.

Actualizing this collective power, however, requires public health to break free from its current mental model. Despite broad acceptance that health is largely determined by social conditions, public health often still focuses on the behaviors of individuals and their access to care. Breaking free of this solely biomedical understanding of health requires a disciplined appreciation of the structural nature of inequities — that they arise from unfair and unjust laws, policies, regulations, funding flows, practices, and norms rooted in racism and other forms of oppression, and are defined by the narratives that shape society. To date, such an appreciation has largely given rise to efforts at making policies more equitable or multi-systems work that better accounts for health (such as “health in all policies”). Although these efforts have sometimes borne fruit, governmental public health is largely limited in what it can do, partly due to restrictions to lobbying and partly because practitioners have a (quite understandable) tendency to compromise when the work gets contentious. By contrast, communities do not have the same restrictions and are less likely to compromise given that their lives are at stake. All in all, a disciplined understanding of the structural nature of inequities drives home that the mental model required for population-wide health is not biomedical but the collective pursuit of fairness and justice.

The Centrality of Trust-Based Relationships

For public health, being part of that collective pursuit needs to start by building relationships with communities. This needs to move beyond the current practice of health departments engaging community-based organizations (CBO) to individuals in public health spending time with individual community members. How that time is spent is key. Public health’s tendency to explain health and extract community input to inform interventions needs to be replaced by the primary aim of building relationships. This requires exchanging thinking, experiences, and values and is only possible if each party, person or group is equally valued. This kind of intentional relationship-building can foster trust, and it is through trust-based relationships that community members will share the realities of their lives. In turn, public health practitioners can share the realities of their work, including acknowledging the harms of some past practices.

These trust-based relationships create the conditions to learn and define challenges together. While public health scholarship has shown that health is determined by multiple systems, community members can go past this reductive description and explain the lived realities of synergistic system failures — how, for instance, inadequate access to employment opportunities, housing, education, and health care all interact to create relentlessly pathogenic conditions. Hence, it is imperative that public health practitioners and scholars engage in ongoing, intentional dialogue with communities to deepen a shared understanding of how structural unfairness and injustices shape daily life, including how they impact health. This also includes a mutual understanding and valuing of how communities’ knowledge, experience, and power can change their circumstances in collaboration with public health.

This brings us back to the idea that communities have power — and a form of power that public health does not. From the mental model that population-wide health comes from a collective pursuit of fairness and justice it follows that part of public health’s role should be to use its positional power — the power it has by virtue of being a formal system — to help communities build and wield their power, including overcoming the forces that limit their power. In this regard, communities will co-lead the pursuit of health equity. This is, of course, one way of saying that the pursuit of health equity requires social movements. Modern-day public health emanated from social reform movements, and our description of inside-outside strategies is very much about showing how it might return to its roots.

Social reform movements were — and are — clear that fairness and justice do not arise from single changes in single systems brought about by plans that are adhered to from start to finish (which is how, for the most part, public health works). Instead, what’s needed is multi-system and iterative, a process that requires constant inquiry and navigation, and is comfortable with handling complexity that is often cultural, political, and relational all at once. In embracing complexity, strategies and tactics become not only interventions to improve fairness and justice (and hence, in time, health) but also means to test new ways of working and learning together, helping to inform the next cycle of strategies and tactics. In essence, a culture of collective praxis ensues, one of constantly doing and reflecting in which experiences, thinking and values are constantly shared, trust-based relationships are formed and deepened, collective learning is enhanced, and the building and wielding of collective power is improved.

To Begin Again

We know that many public health practitioners will be challenged by our proposed changes: public health has urgent work and the changes proposed will divert us from that; public health, especially government public health, operates within a bureaucracy that won’t accommodate such ways of working; and public health simply does not have the resources, especially the workforce, for such work.

To the first we simply say that our current approach to the urgent work is not working well or equitably enough — doing more of the same without making space for something new makes little sense. To the second we say that all bureaucracies — and the systems and structures they create — need to be challenged so that they adapt to the ever-changing environment. To the third we say that truly embracing the mental model that population-wide health arises from a collective pursuit of fairness and justice draws more resources into the work, especially the resources in communities. It’s true, however, that too few in public health have the skills required for the kind of relational work described. However, training courses and communities of practice are forming and the profession needs to support their development.

In our article on inside-outside strategies, we suggested that they are how public health could see itself as part of an ecosystem of organizations pursuing fairer and more just social arrangements. Given the growing crisis of trust and the very real health consequences for some communities, however, we believe that even inside-outside strategies will struggle without centering the need to build trust-based relationships. It is from these relationships that we can acknowledge the humanity and power of all at the table, establish a collective understanding of population-wide health, and build consensus on how to act in concert.

Ultimately, the crisis in trust in public health is about a lack of respect and understanding. Remedying that sustainably requires a rethink of what public health is, one that takes it back to its roots in social reform. Public health is not about biomedicine, even if biomedical metrics are part of how it measures performance. It’s about a collective pursuit of societal fairness and justice within which formal public health plays only a part. Creating this renewed form of public health may seem daunting but, as our article illustrated, in some places the process has already started. The job at hand is to bring together these examples into a coherent, persuasive, and followable whole. The fact that that the “whole” looks much like where public health started is not a coincidence. The profession needs to begin again. Daunting though this may seem, the current crisis of trust may well be the impetus needed to get started.

Acknowledgements: Pritpal S Tamber’s contribution to this article was partly made possible by a grant from The California Endowment.


Citation:
Tamber PS, Welter CR, Barnett GM, Iton A. To Begin Again: Renewing Public Health’s Mental Model. Milbank Quarterly Opinion. November 13, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1599/mqop.2026.11.13