The Fund supports several networks of state health policymakers to help identify, inspire, and inform policy leaders.
The Milbank Memorial Fund supports two state leadership programs for legislative and executive branch state government officials committed to improving population health.
The Fund identifies and shares policy ideas and analysis on topics important to state health policymakers, particularly on issues related to state leadership, primary care, aging, and health care costs.
Keep up with news and updates from the Milbank Memorial Fund. And read the latest blogs from our thought leaders, including Fund President Christopher F. Koller.
The Fund publishes The Milbank Quarterly, as well as reports, issues briefs, and case studies on topics important to health policy leaders.
The Milbank Memorial Fund is is a nonpartisan foundation focused on improving the health of communities and entire populations.
May 20, 2020
Primary Care Transformation Delivery System Reform Primary Care Investment COVID-19
Christopher F. Koller
Dec 17, 2021
Dec 15, 2021
Sep 28, 2021
Back to The View from Here
This week I got a bit of nice news from my auto insurer. The COVID-19 pandemic has meant fewer people are driving. Fewer miles driven means fewer accidents and fewer auto insurance payouts.
Pending regulatory approval, I am to get a credit for March and April on my insurance premiums. (Regulators, you know what to do.)
The same slowdown is happening in health care spending, but I am not holding my breath for a similar insurance rebate. Instead, I want leaders to seize the opportunity to reorient the health care system that was so ill-prepared for the current crisis.
Since March, there has been an unprecedented collapse in the volume of health care services in the United States. As health providers actually started to act more like a system and gear up to respond heroically to the horrifying toll of the pandemic and mitigate its spread, elective surgeries, diagnostic procedures, and follow-up visits were cancelled. As a result, according to an Altarum Institute analysis of federal reports, March overall health care spending was 5.5% lower than the same period last year, the first decline in 30 years of measurement.
Advocates for health-care-cost curve bending sat up and took notice. Had COVID-19 achieved the impossible and tamed the “confiscatory” beast that is gobbling up public budgets and employer benefits?
But the impact of the activity reduction has been bloody and indiscriminate. Outpatient visits are estimated to have dropped by nearly 60%. Providers with the weakest finances—including those offering needed services like rural health and primary care—have been most affected, with many laying off staff and experiencing serious cash flow problems. The big-guy health care systems are dipping into their sizable reserves.
Federal stimulus money for health care to date has favored large institutional providers, not the most financially vulnerable ones. Pressure has built on commercial insurers—beneficiaries of this drop in spending—to be more active in their support of these providers, who might shut down or get consolidated into larger, more expensive health care systems.
Not so fast. Why the rush to rebuild a health system that is leaving us so vulnerable to this pandemic?
And the effect of this decreased activity on patient health has been uncertain at best. Emergency room visits and pediatric immunizations have declined. On the other hand, it is reasonable to assume that a disproportionate amount of the activity reduction has been in the $200 billion/year of low-value care—such as nonurgent emergency room visits and duplicative or unnecessary diagnostic testing—the National Academy of Medicine estimated is provided every year. “The coronavirus has done more to reduce low-value care than 10 years of value-based purchasing,” one sage tweeted.
Now, with varied and politically charged efforts by states to open up their economies, attention is focused on reopening up the health care sector and gearing up for all those elective procedures. The push is strong. Providers are eager to restore revenues. Patients want to see real and perceived needs addressed. Political leaders see public morale and jobs on the line.
Not so fast. Why the rush to rebuild a health system that is leaving us so vulnerable to this pandemic? Now is a unique time for policymakers and purchasers alike to use their leverage to push for changes—to help remake a US health care delivery system with the dubious distinction of being the most expensive in the world while delivering declining life expectancies.
Where to begin? In the eagerness to reopen health care, employers, purchasers, and policymakers should prioritize activities that:
These are public challenges that require coordinated, collective responses. There are important private sector partnerships to be made and roles to played, but we cannot expect employers, providers, and payers—many with deep investments in the status quo—to solve them individually.
There will be worker dislocation and resource reallocation accompanying these responses, but that meteor has already struck. Nearly 1.5 million health care workers lost their jobs in March and April. Public officials are right. We need to get them back into the workforce. But rather than redeploying them back into our treatment-oriented, administratively burdensome delivery system, they can be engaged in the work of prevention, primary care, and community-based services—roles with greater impact on societal health now and in the future.
I am not holding my breath for my health insurance premium discount. Unlike auto insurance, I did not pay the full premium for my health insurance. Unlike auto accidents, many medical services have been deferred, not prevented, especially when providers are paid for each service. But this is not a moment just to rebuild, restore, or reopen health care as it was before. It is an opportunity to reorient our system to the new realities we face with a virus in our midst, as well as the persistent ones of high cost and poor performance. We need to be up to the challenge.
Get the Latest from the Milbank Memorial Fund
An endowed operating foundation that engages in nonpartisan analysis, collaboration, and communication, with an emphasis on state health policy.