Give the People What They Want…If You Can Find Out What That Is

Focus Area:
State Health Policy Leadership
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

This November, voters could not be misunderstood. They wanted change in Washington and in several state capitols. While polls predicted this outcome, they did not predict how loudly voters would speak.

Still, different interpretations of what change voters want to see abound. Is this a call for a better economy, a new foreign policy, a different political tone, renewed trust in science—or is it an overall rebuke to the current administration? The answer is most certainly YES to all, but to what extent for each? Government officials will have to prioritize issues, and make thousands of policy and operational decisions to implement those priorities, within the bounds of their authority and the law. They will also have to consider all of the people they serve, not just the ones who voted, or who voted for their side. This includes those who are hard to hear between elections from inside government.

The conversation about trust in government and science has evolved, moving from how to better message governmental decisions, to how to better listen to those affected by government decisions, to a call for collaborating and co-creating policy with communities. As part of CDC’s reform efforts after COVID, I led the agency toward that co-creation by developing a systematic approach to agency guidance development. Despite broad acknowledgement that the guidance development process needed to change, there were very strong headwinds, some of which are still present today.

Following the Science

The most obvious source of resistance was the traditional public health culture of “following the science.” Yet, evidence rarely pointed to only one policy option, so what I started to hear in those conversations was “follow the scientist.”

Through many tough conversations, we at CDC developed a process that was more multidisciplinary, more transparent, and more externally engaged. We had a chance to begin implementing these reforms, but before the culture change could take hold, the agency was thrust into an existential crisis.

Providing transparency and meaningful engagement in federal processes is hard, but it doesn’t need to be as hard as it is. Aside from culture, we had some legal and procedural constraints—all well intentioned—that led to less engagement:

  • The Federal Advisory Committee Act (FACA) governs how federal agencies can seek recommendations from non-governmental parties. While the law only applies to consensus recommendations, a culture of caution at many federal agencies creates a powerful disincentive to convene stakeholders for policy input. While designed to promote transparency and equal access to government decision-making, FACA committees are hard to navigate for many interested parties: membership is limited and nominations and vetting are bureaucratic processes, and sharing input with the committee requires time and attention most regular citizens don’t have to give.
  • The Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA) requires federal agencies to get permission from the Office of Management and Budget (OBM) to ask the same questions of more than nine individuals. You can imagine how many nine-person discussions this led to, since OMB clearance required a ton of paperwork (ironically), and many months of lead time.
  • The Administrative Procedures Act (APA) governs regulations and certain guidelines and guidance. The notice and comment requirements are meant to open decision making to the public, yet the complex, legal language in the policy documents can obscure the policy impact for most citizens. Moreover, during certain parts of the process, agencies are forbidden from communicating with outside parties, and often agencies see this as a total ban on engagement prior to rulemaking.

While these are federal rules, many states have similar barriers in statute or regulation, and some federal rules roll down to state and local government when federal funding is involved (e.g., PRA).

Changing the Rules and Norms

These processes were designed with best intentions. If we still have the goal of providing equal access to government decision-making, these policies need to change. They have not only failed to create the equal access they envisioned but also serve as roadblocks between government and citizens. Although you no longer have to examine the Federal Register in person, these processes—while online—haven’t changed much this century. Meanwhile, the vast opportunities available for information exchange have gone mostly untapped for public engagement.

Outside of the legal constraints, there is also a reluctance to share deliberations, especially with people who might disagree. This makes sense: we want to lay out the policy rationale, and tipping our hand to those who might oppose policies gives them a chance to build opposition and shape the conversation in ways that could undermine our policy aims. However, we also lose out on an opportunity to build trust.

In his piece on public health and power in The Milbank Quarterly, Jonathan C. Heller identified this lack of engagement as a root cause of ineffective public health interventions and recommends that health leaders move beyond expertise and moral authority to employ other forms of power, requiring deep, trusting relationships with community groups and democratizing data and evidence. Similarly, Karl Johnson and Zoey Kernodle identify engagement as a tool for “mutual knowing” rather than for promoting adherence, a change that requires different skills and methods than traditional public health practice. In our recent webinar, State Policy Levers for Infectious Disease Control, every panelist emphasized trust building as the most important action for government, not more funding, better data, or increased access to vaccines and therapeutics (although those are important, too).

In both the statutory and practical constraints, government caution gets in the way of transparency and engagement, and this makes public policy less informed and less likely to meet its aims. To build trust, and indeed to build effective public policy, government leaders need to bust through these barriers. That means having less-conservative interpretations of laws that limit flexibility, and modernizing those rules to capitalize on new ways to engage. It also means taking the risk of bringing in outside views, including possibly conflicting opinions when they can still influence the decision, not just the messaging strategy.

This month’s elections showed us the direction that our states and nation want to go, and although there may be a tide, it is not going in one direction on all the issues all the time. Policy solutions require nuance and detail that no election can fully inform. Our job now is to keep the people’s voice at the center of health policy.

In a new open letter published by Milbank earlier this month, nine former HHS secretaries offered a range of health policy ideas to incoming governors for consideration. As transition teams prepare to take office, they should also consider how they will incorporate communities into the development of their signature health policies.